1) What the channel is (content + positioning)

Free Telegram channel centered on EURUSD and GOLD. Reviews describe frequent forecasts and signals, with a tilt toward swing-style setups (4H–1D) that can take longer to complete. One recurring complaint: stop-loss is sometimes missing, making execution harder for day traders. This review keeps the focus on how those patterns affect real outcomes.

What you typically get

• Directional forecasts with key levels
• MT4 screenshots / trade result screenshots (real vs demo not always clear)
• High posting cadence (claims of ~3 forecasts per day, ~1000 views each)

2) Snapshot: two sources side by side

One full-year dataset reports 478 free signals with a 25% win rate and -5,592 pips. The review points to a win-rate vs payoff mismatch as the core issue, yielding negative expectancy despite some large winners.

4) Monthly free-signal table (Sep 2024 → Aug 2025)

High volatility: singles can spike above +140 pips or drop to the mid -40s, yet month-end sums stay negative.

5) Red flags and community feedback

• Free-signal win rate sits around 25% in the dataset; negative net pips.
• Stops are sometimes missing; targets can take days, making execution harder for intraday traders.
• Trust score around mid-level (5/10); described as “not a scam, but limited use.”
• Reports of impostor/fake accounts — only use official links.
• Some optimistic reader claims conflict with the backtest results.

6) Why the two reviews diverge

• Counting “forecasts” vs “signals” differently.
• Assumptions about entries, partial TPs, and missing SL.
• Reader-reported results vs strict “count every call” backtesting.

Both agree the channel is active and established; both also imply the free content is hard to execute mechanically and the edge is unclear.

7) Takeaway (50/50)

1. Established, active feed; covers EURUSD and gold.
2. Forecast-heavy format; stops may be missing; targets can be slow.
3. Stats: 478 free signals, 25% win, -5,592 pips; every tracked month negative.
4. Execution friction (no SL, swing timing) makes copy-trading difficult.
5. Bottom line: free signals show negative expectancy; treat forecasts cautiously.